
Switching banks for a better rate is two problems wearing one coat. The first is arithmetic: how many dollars a year the higher rate is worth on the balance you actually hold. The second is sequencing: how to move direct deposits and autopays without a payment failing while the money is in transit.
This post handles both. You get the formula for the gap, the terms that quietly shrink it, an early-withdrawal penalty worked all the way through, what to read in a bonus offer, and a move order that keeps the old account alive until the new one has proven itself.
Every rate below is an FDIC national average as of August 17, 2026: savings 0.38% APY, money market 0.63% APY, 12-month CD 1.71% APY. Those are averages across insured institutions, not quotes from anyone. No bank is named here, and nothing here predicts where rates go next.
The gap in dollars
The formula is short:
Annual gap = balance × (new APY − old APY)
APY already accounts for a year of compounding, so for a balance you leave alone for twelve months, balance times APY is the year’s interest.
Take $25,000 and the three national averages:
| Where the $25,000 sits | National average APY, Aug 17, 2026 | Interest over 12 months |
|---|---|---|
| Savings | 0.38% | $95.00 |
| Money market | 0.63% | $157.50 |
| 12-month CD | 1.71% | $427.50 |
Moving from the savings average to the money market average is $157.50 − $95.00 = $62.50 a year. Moving from the savings average to the 12-month CD average is $427.50 − $95.00 = $332.50 a year.
Convert those to a monthly figure before deciding whether the paperwork is worth it. Using simple monthly proration, rounded to the nearest cent, $62.50 ÷ 12 = $5.21 a month and $332.50 ÷ 12 = $27.71 a month. Twelve rounded months will not add back to the exact annual figure; the annual number is the accurate one.
The part-year version
A move that lands partway through the year only earns the gap for the months that remain. If the transfer completes four months in, eight months carry it: $62.50 × 8 ÷ 12 = $41.67, again by simple proration rounded to the nearest cent.
That is the honest size of the decision. Not a reason to skip the move — a reason to stop agonizing over it.
Partial moves
The formula scales in a straight line, which means you are not choosing between all and nothing. Half the balance produces half the gap. Moving $12,500 of that $25,000 from the savings average to the money market average is $12,500 × 0.25% = $31.25 a year, exactly half of the $62.50 above.
That matters when the higher rate comes with terms you are not sure about. Move a slice, live with the account for a statement cycle or two, confirm the rate posted and the transfer limits behave as written, then move the rest if it holds up.
Timing vs. structure
Deposit APYs are set by each institution. The Federal Reserve’s target range for the federal funds rate is one input to the short-term rate environment, and competition among institutions for deposits is another. Neither tells you what a specific account will pay next month, and this post makes no forecast.
What you can control is structure: where the money sits and which terms bind it. Your deposit agreement states whether your rate is variable and whether the bank must notify you before changing it. A CD disclosure states the rate, the term, and the early-withdrawal penalty in the same document.
Structure is a decision you make once and can verify in writing. Timing is a guess. Spend your attention on the first one.
Terms that change the math
Before you accept the gap you computed, check whether any of these shrink it.
- A balance cap. Some accounts state a maximum balance that earns the headline APY, with a lower rate above it. The disclosure says whether yours does.
- A monthly fee. Convert it to annual dollars and subtract. A $5 monthly fee is $60.00 a year, which leaves only $2.50 of a $62.50 gap.
- A minimum to earn the rate. Confirm whether it is measured as a daily balance or a cycle average.
- A variable rate. A rate that can change is not a twelve-month promise, whatever the annual figure suggests.
Breaking a CD, priced out
CDs generally charge an early-withdrawal penalty stated in the disclosure, often quoted as a number of months of interest. Price it instead of guessing at it.
Take $25,000 at the 1.71% national 12-month average, where a full term earns $427.50. Using simple proration:
- Interest earned by month six: $427.50 × 6 ÷ 12 = $213.75
- A penalty of three months of interest: $427.50 × 3 ÷ 12 = $106.88 (from $106.875, rounded to the nearest cent)
- Net after breaking at month six: $213.75 − $106.88 = $106.87
Compare that with the same $25,000 sitting in savings at the 0.38% average for those six months: $95.00 × 6 ÷ 12 = $47.50. On these numbers the broken CD still finishes $106.87 − $47.50 = $59.37 ahead. Your own penalty terms may produce a different answer. The point is that the penalty is a number you can compute before you commit, not a mystery.
Bonus offers and their conditions
A bonus is quoted in dollars, so it compares directly against the annual gap you just computed. The conditions decide whether you collect it. The written offer should state every one of these:
- The qualifying deposit amount and the deadline to make it.
- How long the money must stay before the bonus posts.
- Whether direct deposit is required, and how the bank defines a qualifying direct deposit.
- The date the bonus is paid.
- Whether the account must stay open for a set period, and the fee for closing early.
- How the bonus is reported for tax purposes.
If any of those is missing from the written offer, treat it as unconfirmed and ask before you fund the account.
A move order that avoids missed payments
Open first, close last. The sequence:
- Open the new account while the old one stays open and funded.
- Send a small test transfer in both directions and note how long each leg takes.
- Pull twelve months of statements from the old account and list every recurring debit and credit.
- Redirect direct deposit, then wait for one full pay cycle to land before moving anything else.
- Move autopays one at a time, confirming each one posts from the new account.
- Leave a buffer in the old account for at least two full statement cycles.
- Close the old account only after two cycles with no unexpected activity, and keep the closing statement.
Weigh the annual gap you computed against the returned-payment and overdraft fees listed in your deposit agreement. Those two numbers together tell you how fast it is sensible to move.
Coverage across two banks
Holding money at two institutions can raise your insured total, but only if they are genuinely two institutions.
Standard FDIC coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category, and credit unions are insured by the NCUA at the same standard limit. Ownership categories — single, joint, certain retirement accounts, revocable trust — are insured separately.
Some brands share a single bank charter, in which case balances at both count once against the same limit. The FDIC’s BankFind tool shows which brands share a charter; check it before assuming a second brand buys you a second $250,000. If a trust is involved, note that the FDIC revised its trust-account rules effective April 1, 2024, and use the FDIC’s EDIE estimator rather than a formula you learned earlier.
A short decision rule
Compute the annual gap on your actual balance. Subtract any monthly fee, in annual dollars. Confirm the rate is not capped above a balance you already hold, and that the money is reachable when you need it. If what survives all that is worth an hour of setup, open the new account, move in the order above, and leave the old one open through two clean statement cycles.
If what survives is a few dollars, that is a real answer too. Write the number down, and stop thinking about it.