
A promotional APY is a real rate applied to real money for a limited time. It is also, quite deliberately, not the number you should compare against another bank’s ongoing rate. The comparison that works is a blended figure: what the account pays across the full period you plan to hold it, promo and post-promo combined.
The arithmetic takes two minutes and changes the ranking of offers more often than you would expect.
The four terms that define any promotion
Every promotional deposit offer comes down to four things, all of which appear in the disclosure:
- The promotional APY — the headline number
- The promotional period — how long it lasts, usually stated in months from account opening
- The reversion rate — what the account pays afterward, sometimes named as “the ongoing variable rate”
- The balance cap — the maximum balance the promotional rate applies to, if there is one
The fourth is the one most often missed. An offer of 5.00% APY on balances up to $10,000, with the standard rate above that, is a different product than 5.00% on everything. If you are placing $40,000, three-quarters of your money never sees the headline number.
Blending promo and reversion into one number
Suppose you are comparing two accounts for $25,000 you expect to hold for a full year:
Offer A: 5.00% APY for the first 4 months, then 2.00% Offer B: 3.40% APY, no promotion, no expiration
Compute the interest each earns over twelve months. Using simple proportions of a year for clarity — the compounding difference at these amounts is a few dollars and does not change the ranking:
Offer A, promotional stretch (4 months = 1/3 year): $25,000 × 0.0500 × (4 ÷ 12) = $416.67
Offer A, remaining 8 months: $25,000 × 0.0200 × (8 ÷ 12) = $333.33
Offer A total: $416.67 + $333.33 = $750.00 Effective APY: $750.00 ÷ $25,000 = 3.00%
Offer B total: $25,000 × 0.0340 = $850.00 Effective APY: 3.40%
Offer B pays $100 more over the year, despite advertising a rate 1.60 percentage points below Offer A’s headline. The blended figure — 3.00% against 3.40% — is the comparison that produces the right answer, and it is the one the marketing never shows.
The formula generalizes cleanly:
Effective APY = (promo APY × promo months + reversion APY × remaining months) ÷ 12
Change the holding period and the answer changes with it. If you genuinely intend to move the money the day the promo ends, Offer A wins on that four-month stretch. The blended number only applies over the period you will actually hold.
What a balance cap does to the same math
Take Offer A again, but with the promotional rate capped at the first $10,000 and the standard 2.00% applying above that.
First $10,000 for 4 months: $10,000 × 0.0500 × (4 ÷ 12) = $166.67 Remaining $15,000 for 4 months: $15,000 × 0.0200 × (4 ÷ 12) = $100.00 All $25,000 for the last 8 months: $25,000 × 0.0200 × (8 ÷ 12) = $333.33
Total: $600.00 — an effective APY of 2.40%, now a full point behind Offer B.
The cap did more damage than the reversion did. When an offer carries one, apply the promotional rate only to the eligible slice.
Why banks offer them at all
Understanding the motive makes the terms easier to read. A promotional rate is a customer-acquisition cost, and the bank is buying one of three things.
New deposits. The most common goal, and the reason “new money only” conditions exist. A bank that wants to grow its funding base gains nothing by paying a higher rate on balances it already holds.
Relationship depth. Offers requiring a direct deposit or a set number of debit transactions are buying your primary banking relationship, not just your cash. Accounts that receive a paycheck are far less likely to leave, which is worth more to the bank than the promotional interest costs.
A specific product’s growth. Sometimes the promotion sits on one term — a 9-month or 13-month CD at an unusual rate. Odd terms like that usually mean the bank is matching a funding need on its own balance sheet, and the rate is real precisely because the need is real.
None of these motives make an offer good or bad. They tell you which conditions are load-bearing. An acquisition offer will enforce the new-money rule strictly. A relationship offer will enforce the direct deposit requirement and may be indifferent about balance size.
Promotional CDs work differently
A promotional rate on a savings or money market account is temporary because the rate is variable. A promotional CD rate is fixed for the full term — the promotion is in the rate itself, not in an expiry partway through.
That makes promotional CDs simpler to evaluate: the advertised APY is the APY for the whole term, no blending required. Two things still deserve a check.
The renewal rate. A promotional 12-month CD frequently rolls into the bank’s standard 12-month rate at maturity, which can be a fraction of the promotional one. The grace period after maturity — usually 7 to 10 days — is your window to move without penalty. Calendar it at opening.
The term length. Promotional terms are often odd numbers chosen by the bank rather than by what suits you. A 13-month CD at an attractive rate is a fine instrument if your money is genuinely idle for 13 months, and an expensive one if you need it at month 11 and pay a penalty measured in months of interest.
Comparing three offers at once
Putting the arithmetic into a single table makes the ranking obvious. Assume $20,000 held for twelve months:
| Offer | Structure | Interest over 12 months | Effective APY |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 5.00% for 3 months, then 1.50% | $250 + $225 = $475 | 2.38% |
| B | 3.60% flat, no promotion | $720 | 3.60% |
| C | 4.50% for 6 months, then 2.75% | $450 + $275 = $725 | 3.63% |
Offer A has the highest headline and the lowest return. Offers B and C finish within $5 of each other, which means the tiebreaker is not the rate at all — it is whether C’s post-promo 2.75% will still look reasonable in six months, and whether either account carries conditions you might miss.
That is the general shape of these comparisons. Once blended, the headline gaps mostly close, and the decision moves to conditions, access, and whether the ongoing rate is one you would accept on its own.
Conditions that can void the rate
Promotional deposit rates frequently attach requirements. Common ones:
- A minimum opening deposit, sometimes required to be new money not already held at that bank
- A recurring direct deposit of a stated size
- A minimum number of debit transactions per statement cycle
- A minimum daily balance, where dipping below it once forfeits the rate for the whole cycle
Miss a condition and the account typically pays the base rate for that period — occasionally a punitive rate well below it. Before counting on any promotional yield, confirm each condition is something that happens automatically in your financial life rather than something you have to remember to do every month. A rate that depends on your memory is not a rate; it is a test.
The “new money” requirement deserves particular attention if you are moving funds within the same institution. Transferring your existing savings into a new promotional account at the same bank often fails to qualify, and the failure is discovered after the fact.
Where promotional rates sit against the market
Context helps calibrate whether an offer is genuinely strong. FDIC national average deposit rates as of August 17, 2026:
| Product | National average APY |
|---|---|
| Savings | 0.38% |
| Interest checking | 0.07% |
| Money market | 0.63% |
| 12-month CD | 1.71% |
These averages include every insured institution, most of which pay very little, so a competitive account is well above them. What the table is useful for is the reversion rate: if an offer’s post-promo rate sits near the savings average, the account will be unremarkable for however long you leave money in it after the promotion ends. Judge the offer on that number, since that is the one you will live with.
A short checklist before opening
- Write down all four terms — promo APY, period, reversion rate, balance cap
- Blend them across your actual holding period using the formula above
- Compare blended figures across offers, never headline against ongoing
- Confirm every qualifying condition happens without effort on your part
- Calendar the promotion’s end date the day you open the account
- Confirm the institution is FDIC-insured (or NCUA-insured, for credit unions) and that your total balance there stays within the coverage limit
Step 5 is the one that converts a good decision into a good outcome. A promotional account you forget about becomes a low-rate account holding your money at the reversion rate, and that is how a strong opening turns into an ordinary year.
Rates cited are FDIC national averages as of August 17, 2026. Promotional terms, caps, and qualifying conditions vary by institution and change frequently — the disclosure you receive at account opening governs.