
Moving money from one CD into another is an arithmetic problem, and the arithmetic is short. You need four numbers: what your current CD pays, what the new one pays, what the early-withdrawal penalty costs if you leave before maturity, and how long the money will actually sit. Get those four right and the decision usually makes itself.
This post covers where deposit rates sit on a national basis right now, how maturity and grace periods create exit points that cost nothing, how penalties are figured, and how to move funds between institutions without dropping insurance coverage. There is a full worked example with every figure shown, so you can rerun it with your own balance.
What this post will not do is tell you where rates are going. Nobody knows that. The approaches below are built so the answer doesn’t depend on it.
The rate map as of August 17, 2026
The FDIC publishes national average deposit rates by account type. These are the figures as of August 17, 2026:
| Account or term | National average APY |
|---|---|
| Savings | 0.38% |
| Money market | 0.63% |
| 3 month CD | 1.14% |
| 6 month CD | 1.41% |
| 12 month CD | 1.71% |
| 24 month CD | 1.57% |
| 36 month CD | 1.34% |
| 60 month CD | 1.36% |
Two things are worth noticing. The 12 month average is the highest of any term listed, and the averages fall as terms stretch past a year: 1.71% at 12 months against 1.34% at 36 months. And these are averages across all insured institutions, not a menu of available offers. Your own bank’s number can sit well above or well below any line in that table, which is why step one is reading your own disclosure rather than a national figure.
APY is the right number for comparison. APY includes the effect of compounding; a stated interest rate does not. Two CDs quoting the same interest rate can pay different amounts if one compounds daily and the other compounds at maturity, and their APYs will show that difference.
Maturity dates and grace periods
The cheapest moment to move a CD is at maturity, because no penalty applies. Your deposit agreement states the length of the grace period that follows maturity — the window in which you can withdraw, add funds, or change the term without a penalty. It also states what happens if you do nothing, which is typically automatic renewal into a new term at whatever rate is in effect on the renewal date.
Three items to pull from your paperwork before any decision:
- The exact maturity date and the length of the grace period after it.
- The renewal terms: which term the CD rolls into, and when the renewal rate is set.
- The pre-maturity notice the bank sends, and the mailing address or inbox it goes to.
Set a calendar reminder a week before maturity and you arrive at that window with time to act. It is the one stretch of the term in which no early-withdrawal penalty applies.
Early-withdrawal penalty arithmetic
Break a CD before maturity and the bank applies the penalty stated in your disclosure. Penalties are commonly quoted as a number of months of interest; the exact count is on that document, as is whether the penalty can reach into principal when the CD has not yet earned that much interest. Have both numbers in front of you before running any comparison.
A worked comparison
You hold $10,000 in a 36 month CD paying 1.34% APY, with 12 months left to run. A 12 month CD is available at 1.71% APY. Both figures are the FDIC national averages for those terms as of August 17, 2026, used here as stand-ins for the numbers on your own paperwork. The disclosure sets the penalty at six months of interest and allows it to reduce principal.
Convention: the penalty is figured as simple monthly proration of the stated rate on principal, and each APY is applied once across a full 12 months. Real accounts compound inside the year; this simplification keeps every step checkable by hand.
Option A — leave it alone for 12 months. Interest: $10,000.00 × 1.34% = $134.00 Ending balance: $10,000.00 + $134.00 = $10,134.00
Option B — break it and move. Penalty: $10,000.00 × 1.34% × (6 ÷ 12) = $67.00 Amount transferred: $10,000.00 − $67.00 = $9,933.00 Interest for 12 months: $9,933.00 × 1.71% = $169.85 (unrounded, $169.8543) Ending balance: $9,933.00 + $169.85 = $10,102.85
Staying ahead by $10,134.00 − $10,102.85 = $31.15.
The headline gap of 0.37 percentage points is not what decides the outcome. The penalty is charged against the full $10,000, while the higher rate earns only on the $9,933 that survives it.
For the break-even: the new rate would have to lift $9,933.00 to $10,134.00, which needs a factor of $10,134.00 ÷ $9,933.00 = 1.020236 — roughly 2.02% APY. Against 1.34%, that is a required gap of about 0.68 percentage points, nearly double the 0.37 that started the exercise.
Three ways to arrange the money
- A single term. Everything in one CD. Simplest to track, and the whole balance is locked until one date.
- A ladder. The balance split into equal pieces across staggered terms, so one piece matures each year. Each maturity is a penalty-free decision point.
- A barbell. Only short and long terms, nothing in between, with the short end holding near-term cash and the long end holding a fixed rate for years.
The ladder has a cost you can price out. Split $10,000 into five $2,000 pieces at 12, 24, 36, 48, and 60 months, using the August 17, 2026 national averages of 1.71%, 1.57%, 1.34%, 1.27%, and 1.36%. Those five rates sum to 7.25%, so the blended first-year yield is 7.25% ÷ 5 = 1.45%, and first-year interest is $10,000.00 × 1.45% = $145.00. Putting the entire $10,000 in the 12 month term instead would earn $10,000.00 × 1.71% = $171.00. The ladder gives up $171.00 − $145.00 = $26.00 in year one, and in exchange one rung comes free every twelve months.
Transfer mechanics between institutions
Once the decision is made, the mechanics decide how many days the money earns nothing.
- Open the receiving CD first, then fund it. The funding window for a newly opened CD is stated in its own disclosure.
- Decide which side initiates the transfer, then ask that institution for its posting schedule before you start.
- Check whether the sending bank mails a paper check at maturity by default. Funds traveling as a paper check are not earning in either account.
- If the CD sits inside an IRA, ask the receiving institution for a direct transfer so the funds never pass through your hands, and confirm your own tax situation with a tax professional.
Insurance limits during a move
FDIC standard coverage is $250,000 per depositor, per insured bank, per ownership category. Credit unions are insured by the NCUA at the same standard limit. Ownership categories — single, joint, certain retirement accounts, revocable trust — are insured separately, so one person can be covered for more than $250,000 at one bank across different categories.
A transfer can briefly push one side above the limit, since the old CD may still be open while the new one is funded. Two checks are worth making. The FDIC’s BankFind tool shows which brand names share a single charter; two brands on one charter share one $250,000 limit per category rather than getting one each. And if trust accounts are involved, note that the FDIC’s trust coverage rules were revised effective April 1, 2024, so older formulas circulating online may not describe your situation. Run the numbers through the FDIC’s EDIE estimator instead of working from a remembered rule.
One more distinction matters at any bank that also sells investments: deposits at a failed insured bank are covered, and investments are not.
A short pre-move checklist
Before authorizing anything, have these on one page: the maturity date and grace period, the penalty as written in the disclosure, the current APY, the new APY, and the balance. Run the two options the way the worked example does — ending balance against ending balance, not rate against rate — and keep the penalty on the full principal where it belongs.
If a move clears that test, it clears it whatever rates do next. If it fails, the calendar reminder before maturity gets you to the same destination for free.